"Brain gym" and "bad science"

"Brain gym" and "bad science"

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 0
As exam time approaches, your mind might stray towards that fickle phenomenon, concentration. As we keep being told, some things boost your concentration, whilst others don’t. Eating a healthy breakfast will get you through the day, drinking water is good for you, a hangover will impede yourbrain by jj_judes on flickr concentration, caffeine can be a stimulant, too much caffeine can make you feel jittery, get a good night’s rest, exercise. The advice is often based on common sense, and sometimes backed up by scientific reasoning. A recent study entitled “The seductive allure of neuroscience explanations”* revealed that “even irrelevant neuroscience information in an explanation of a psychological phenomenon may interfere with people's abilities to critically consider the underlying logic of this explanation”; it suggests that many of us are more likely to trust scientific sounding statements than our ability to reason logically.

Remember you don’t need to be a trained scientist to reason.

Earlier this month Newsnight reported on Brain gym®, a commercial programme used in many primary schools. You can watch the segment on

here.

At 3’03’’ an ‘accredited brain gym consultant’ states, “there’s an exercise we do called “energy on”, where you rub the cheek muscles and you kind of relax the tension in the jaw and the cheeks. If we release the tension in the jaw, we’re releasing problems with the temporomandibular joints and underneath the temporomandibular joint five of the cranial nerves kind of come out and they feed forward into the face and they improve languaging…”

I did not know what the temporomandibular joint is, but I do know that with the very last word she contradicts herself beautifully. Is it a verb? Is it a noun? It’s both? The statement hardly suggests very high 'languaging' skills.

Better perhaps to stick to common sense. The goldsmiths counselling service has a few exam tips here, entirely free of charge and none of which entail rubbing your 'Brain Buttons'!


If you’re interested in pseudo-science debunking, then Ben Goldacre’s blog is both entertaining and informative (and brain gym is one of his bugbears).

*in: Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience [Mar 2008, 20(3): pp. 470-7]

(Image by jj_judes on flickr)